• 0 Posts
  • 39 Comments
Joined 24 days ago
cake
Cake day: March 13th, 2025

help-circle









  • Unfortunately that is one of the downsides. People will abuse the rules and dance all along the line for nefarious reasons. Can’t plug that hole without potentially stripping others of their ability to speak up in certain ways and situations.

    I actually had a long conversation with friends about that yesterday. We were talking about how someone wasn’t outright saying to kill anyone but they were playing propaganda videos of someone else that was saying those things. Do we hold them responsible for the words of the video they were playing on stream for everyone or is that a clear separation?

    So we have the classic conundrum. Do we want a system where innocent people might accidentally go to prison or do we want a system where people who should go to prison sometimes don’t because we would rather never put innocent people behind bars.




  • You make fair points. Nah private spaces can do whatever they want. You would kick someone out of your house if they were saying things you vehemently disagreed with or found offensive.

    Places like Lemmy, reddit, twitter and so on are ostensibly the modern “public square”. So curtailing certain speech becomes a bit more complicated in my opinion. It’s not quite like the cake shop situation as that is a private place of business.

    Whether or not you believe places like Lemmy and reddit should be treated as basically “public spaces” is up to you. Honestly I could go both ways on it. It’s complicated.

    As for the free speechers and the different specifics at the tiny detail level I don’t really have a good answer for you honestly. I personally operate under the same levels of freedom of speech that the US government has. And they do have exceptions for various things and you could absolutely make the argument that a true freedom of speech believer wouldn’t allow any limitations to be placed on it in any way. That’s a conversation I have had with friends many times. Unfortunately we never really come to any concrete conclusions on it.