

Yeah, this is exactly it. It’s just misgendering and stereotyping under the guise of woke terminology.
Blindly substituting “man” with “an AMAB” and “woman” with “an AFAB” is just moving backwards. How are we supposed to interpret as anything other than “your journey, physical changes, and identity do not matter”?
I’m sorry about that experience :(
I’m glad I’ve found people who relate to this though; I’ve honestly been feeling very isolated even (maybe especially) within the trans community about this.





I hear you. I think in those contexts (health, dating) it is relevant but also conveyed by simply mentioning being trans, or that you have/don’t have a certain body part, or whatever.
Online registration forms are changing for the worse. They used to ask what your gender is, now they’re starting to ask what your “birth assigned sex” is, often without even asking about gender at all. This is also just counterproductive for whatever reason they’re asking this in the first place (if it’s even relevant); I am physiologically very different from a cis woman and my body runs on a male hormone profile. The way I see this is it’s people going “well trans people messed up the definition of gender, so I’m going to ask what was in their pants instead.”
The right way to do this is “what is your gender” and “does this align with the gender you were assigned at birth”? That captures way more useful information about the individual while also being more tactful.
Re this, I honestly reject the notion of an “AFAB childhood” entirely. I had the childhood of a trans guy, which is very different from the childhood of a cis girl. I think lumping them in together like that does more harm than good. I appreciate that my opinion on this is probably influenced by the fact that I figured myself out at a young age (11 or so, I am 28 now), so for me that terminology is straight up erasure. I have worked too hard in my life for too long to be the man that I am, for people to decide to lump me and my experiences in the same bucket as those of cis women and some nonbinary people. It isn’t accurate or informed.