• 0 Posts
  • 75 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 30th, 2023

help-circle

  • Star Wars ships being faster is dependent on them following pre-charted hyperspace lanes. If something isn’t on a hyperspace lane, they have to travel at sub-light speeds. The Enterprise could warp to the other side of the star system in an instant and then wait hours for a Star Destroyer to catch up. Or go to the neighboring system that isn’t on a hyperspace lane and wait years for them. On the other hand, the ISD could cross the galaxy in a few days, provided there’s a charted path there.


  • Yeah, it’s easy to have a prequel character that doesn’t show up in the original and have that make sense, but technology is much harder to explain away. You generally need some form of major societal collapse to explain why tech in a prequel isn’t around anymore. So long as anyone knows how to make the tech, it will come back. Even someone just being aware that the tech existed can result in someone reinventing it.

    This isn’t too difficult to accomplish if the setting is before the information age to begin with, but it’s much harder to justify if the internet or an equivalent is around. We lost the secret of how to make concrete for about a thousand years following the collapse of Rome. On the other hand, David Hahn built a nuclear reactor in his home with just books from the library. Those books are now available any time you want on that neat rectangle you keep in your pocket, and we know from experience that you can’t really scrub anything from the internet, so they’ll always be there so long as the internet still exists.

    Somewhere out there on the Klingon portion (and probably the Romulan portion) of Trek’s internet equivalent are detailed accounts of the USS Discovery, her crew, and her spore drive. The ship was operating completely in the open, after all. And since the Klingons never classified that info, it would be easily and readily available to anyone who can read Klingon or has access to a universal translator.








  • They made up an excuse about how there was ‘no room’ for promotions, except they demoted Paris for a while which would have freed up a spot for Kim. Also, Kim being an ensign when he’s in charge of all of Ops doesn’t make any sense; he has lieutenants and possibly lieutenant commanders under him.

    Out of universe, Berman said that someone absolutely had to be the rookie, even after seven years in deep space, so Kim couldn’t get promoted or meaningfully grow. He also tried to fire Wang a few times for nebulous reasons, only backing off when Wang got a ‘sexiest man on TV’ award. Wang was also the only Star Trek cast member to ever be denied the opportunity to direct an episode, courtesy of Berman. Wang also once said of Berman, “if there is a hell in this existence that we have that people can go to, he’s first on the list.”

    So, short answer is that Berman is scum.